Mortgage Daily Logo

Judge Rules in Favor of DPA Firm

Mortgage News

Mortgage Daily

                                                 March 4, 2008

A federal judge has ordered the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development hold off on implementing a rule banning seller funded downpayment assistance.

U.S. District Judge Lawrence K. Karlton has ruled in favor of Nehemiah Corporation of America in its lawsuit against HUD Secretary Alphonso Jackson and the agency in a lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California.

HUD had finalized a rule on Oct. 1, 2007, prohibiting DPA funded by a home seller or anyone that financially benefits from the transaction or is reimbursed directly or indirectly by the seller. HUD’s position was that FHA loans with seller-funded DPA have risk of default that is two to three times greater. The agency said loans with DPA were involved in nearly a third of its real estate owned portfolio.

That rule was slated to go into effect on March 31, 2008.

Nehemiah’s lawsuit, filed by Weiner Brodsky Sidman Kider PC, sought judicial review of the rule, as well as declaratory and injunctive relief.

AmeriDream Inc., another DPA firm, also sued HUD. In that lawsuit, Genesis Foundation Inc. and Home Downpayment Gift Foundation Inc. successfully intervened as plaintiffs.

Nehemiah alleged in its lawsuit that HUD violated the Administrative Procedures Act by adopting the rule barring DPA on loans insured by the Federal Housing Administration. The organization asserted that the defendants acted arbitrarily and capriciously in issuing the rule.

“In particular, Nehemiah claims that HUD failed to provide a reasoned analysis for the departure from its previous policy, ignored reasonable alternatives to the final rule, relied on data that it never produced for public comment, and prejudged the merits of the final rule,” the order stated.

Nehemiah began exploiting a loophole in HUD’s ban on seller funded DPA in the 1990s by developing a transaction where a charity would make a gift to the borrower with the understanding that the seller would make a donation to the charity once the loan closed, the judge wrote. HUD’s ban didn’t apply in these transactions because the seller’s donation was used to fund a future transaction.

HUD had argued that in addition to suffering more defaults on loans with seller funded DPA, borrowers wound up paying more for the property as the price was inflated to accommodate the seller’s donation. And because FHA financing is more prevalent in depreciating markets, losses on defaulted loans are compounded.

The order noted that HUD did not acknowledge a change in its position.

“Put differently, while HUD may have set forth good reasons for the rule’s adoption, it did not adequately explain why it was changing its mind,” the judge wrote. “Accordingly, while HUD provided substantive analysis to support the rule, it failed to acknowledge its previous position, thereby violating the APA.”

HUD also neglected to consider any reasonable recommended alternatives — such as raising premiums on loans with DPA or disclosing DPA to appraisers — in violation of its duties under APA, the court found.

Bloomberg news story was cited where Jackson indicated during the public comment period the rule would go into effect regardless of critical comments. In his order, the judge noted this was “troubling.”

The judge granted a summary judgment in favor of Nehemiah. He also set aside the final rule and remanded HUD for further action in line with the order, though Jackson has been disqualified from participating in the remanded proceedings.

Mitchel H. Kider, managing partner at Weiner Brodsky, explained that if HUD desires to promulgate another downpayment assistance rule, it would have to start from scratch.

We are confident that had HUD gone through proper APA rulemaking, the proposed rule would not have been finalized,” Kider stated.

“We are thrilled with the Court’s decision,” Nehemiah said in an announcement. “This is a major and conclusive judgment, leaving no uncertainty that downpayment assistance is a life line to the families that Nehemiah serves.”

Related:

HUD Forced to Delay DPA Rule
A federal judge has determined that the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development cannot selectively grant waivers to its rule disallowing seller-funded downpayment assistance on loans insured by the Federal Housing Administration, and has ordered the agency to temporarily halt implementation of the regulation. The move clears the way for all DPA firms to continue offering their services to FHA borrowers for an additional four months.

DPA Fight Goes On
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development has granted AmeriDream Inc. another four months to continue providing seller assisted downpayments on government-insured loans. The move provides more time for the two parties to battle in court.

AmeriDream, Nehemiah Sue HUD
A final ruling on seller-assisted downpayments by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development has prompted organizations dependent on such programs to file lawsuits against the agency.

DPA DOA
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development has said no to seller funded downpayment assistance on federally insured loans.

Related Posts

Federal Housing Administration$1,224.5 billionDec. 31

Third-Quarter 2012 Mortgage Litigation Index

Lawsuits involving excessive fees, servicing fees and loan fees beyond state maximums. Defendant Plaintiff Court Amount Overview Case Title Case Number Date Filed Date of Activity Link to Story Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Orangeburg County, Richland County, South...

Federal Housing Administration$1,224.5 billionDec. 31

Net Branch Lawsuits

Litigation involving net branch operations. Defendant Plaintiff Court Amount Overview Case Title Case Number Date Filed Date of Activity Link to Story PHH Mortgage Corp. Mathews Supreme Court of Virginia na Court held that the term "branch office" includes not only...

Federal Housing Administration$1,224.5 billionDec. 31

Whistleblower Lawsuits

Litigation related to loan servicing, including escrow issues, transfer of servicing and servicing borrowers in bankruptcy and foreclosure.   Defendant Plaintiff Court Amount Overview Case Title Case Number Date Filed Date of Activity Link to Story Bank of...

Federal Housing Administration$1,224.5 billionDec. 31

Mortgage Servicing Lawsuits

Litigation related to loan servicing, including escrow issues, transfer of servicing and servicing borrowers in bankruptcy and foreclosure. Defendant Plaintiff Court Amount Overview Case Title Case Number Date Filed Date of Activity Link to Story BAC Home Loan...

Popular posts

How Long Does It Take to Refinance a Mortgage
How Long Does It Take to Refinance a Mortgage

So, you’re interested in refinancing your mortgage. Maybe you want some extra capital to do that home project you’ve always dreamed of, interest rates are nearing record lows, or you want to start consolidating debt. Regardless of the motivation behind the refinance,...

How Does Refinancing a Mortgage Work
How Does Refinancing a Mortgage Work

A home purchase is considered an investment, and a robust one at that. Savvy owners are constantly looking for new ways to reduce debt, save money, pay less in interest, and ultimately build equity. Refinancing is one way to leverage your investment and do just that....

What Does It Mean to Refinance Your Home
What Does It Mean to Refinance Your Home

You can think of refinancing your mortgage as a debt redo. Essentially, you’ll swap out the existing loan for a new one - ideally with better terms and conditions. Only this time it could help you save money on high mortgage payments, rather than just borrow it....

Setting up the Utilities in My New House
Setting up the Utilities in My New House

All the tedious, time-consuming paperwork has been signed, sealed, and delivered. Your belongings are packed into what seems like a million boxes and you have a solid plan to haul all your existing furniture to the new place. Just as your boxes and furniture need to...

When Is My First Mortgage Payment Due?
When Is My First Mortgage Payment Due?

Navigating your way through a brand-new mortgage loan can be a difficult task, especially for first-time homeowners.   After handing over a large sum of money for the down payment and closing costs, it’s important to pay attention to the timing of your first...

Newsletter

Don’t worry, we don’t spam