Joint rule sets national floor for AMC oversight. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and five other federal regulators have put in place a national floor for how appraisal management companies are supervised, finalising the “Minimum Requirements for Appraisal Management Companies” rule in 2015.
The joint rule – issued by the OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC, CFPB, FHFA and NCUA – implements Dodd-Frank provisions designed to tighten control of firms that sit between lenders and valuers on residential deals, particularly for federally related mortgage transactions.
Who the rule covers – and when it bites
At its core, the rule targets larger AMCs active in the residential market. It applies where an AMC:
-
Oversees a panel of more than 15 state-certified or licensed valuers in one state, or
-
More than 25 valuers across the United States in a given year,
and provides services (such as engaging valuers and managing assignments) for federally related transactions.
Two broad groups are covered:
-
State-regulated AMCs – companies overseen by a state’s appraiser licensing body.
-
Federally regulated AMCs – subsidiaries owned and controlled by a federally regulated bank or similar institution.
The final rule took effect 60 days after publication in the Federal Register in June 2015, with:
-
States given up to three years to build compliant AMC registration regimes; and
-
Federally regulated AMCs are required to meet the minimum standards within 12 months of the effective date.
If a state chooses not to regulate AMCs, non-bank AMCs in that state cannot work on federally related transactions once the three-year window expires.
Key minimum requirements for AMCs
For MortgageDaily readers, the heart of the rule is a set of conditions that must be met if an AMC is to work on federally related mortgage deals in participating states.
1. State registration and supervision
Participating states must run a formal registration and supervision programme for AMCs that meet the size thresholds. That includes:
-
Vetting applications and renewals.
-
Maintaining records on ownership, controlling persons and panel size.
-
Having processes to investigate complaints and take enforcement action.
States then feed data into the Appraisal Subcommittee’s national registry, which tracks eligible AMCs.
2. Use of licensed and certified valuers
To handle assignments tied to federally related transactions, covered AMCs must:
-
Engage only state-certified or licensed valuers in good standing; and
-
Ensure those valuers are properly credentialled in the state where the property is located.
That effectively hard-wires the existing FIRREA and Dodd-Frank expectations on valuer qualifications into the AMC layer of the market.
3. Compliance with USPAP and independence rules
The rule also reinforces two familiar pillars of valuation practice:
-
Standards: AMCs must ensure appraisals comply with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) and any relevant agency rules.
-
Independence: They must maintain safeguards so valuers are free from coercion, conflicts of interest or undue influence by loan production staff, brokers or other parties.
In practice, that means stronger controls around order allocation, fee discussions, reconsideration of value requests and communication between originators and valuers.
4. Ownership and control criteria
To qualify, an AMC must meet minimum ownership and management criteria, including:
-
Having at least one controlling individual who is a state-certified or licensed valuer actively involved in the company’s appraisal operations; and
-
Screening owners and key personnel to ensure they have not been barred or suspended from the valuation profession.
These requirements are intended to keep chronic bad actors out of the AMC channel and to ensure day-to-day decisions are influenced by people with genuine valuation expertise.
Federally regulated vs state-regulated AMCs
A key nuance for compliance teams is the split between state-regulated and federally regulated AMCs:
-
State-regulated AMCs must register with, and are overseen by, a state appraiser licensing agency in any participating state where they operate.
-
Federally regulated AMCs – those owned and controlled by a bank or similar institution supervised by a federal regulator – do not have to register with a state, but they are still subject to the same substantive minimum requirements and to federal supervisory oversight.
That structure allows bank-owned AMCs to operate across state lines without duplicative registration, while still holding them to the same baseline standards on panel management, independence and valuation quality.
What it means for lenders, AMCs and the mortgage market
For lenders and investors, the rule is aimed squarely at reducing valuation-related risk:
-
Tighter control of AMCs should improve consistency and quality of appraisals.
-
A national minimum standard facilitates the assessment of valuation risk in multi-state portfolios.
For AMCs, the impact is more operational:
-
In participating states, larger firms face formal licensing, reporting and examination expectations.
-
They must invest in compliance infrastructure – from ownership vetting to independence controls and record-keeping – to stay on the registry.
-
Smaller firms beneath the size thresholds may see competitive opportunities but will still feel indirect pressure to follow the same good-practice standards.
For states, the rule is a choice point: opt in and build an AMC regime to keep local firms active on federally related transactions – or stay out and accept a narrower universe of eligible providers for those deals.
Bottom line for MortgageDaily readers
The Minimum Requirements for Appraisal Management Companies rule is less about rewriting valuation theory and more about closing a regulatory gap.
By giving the OCC and its fellow agencies a common framework for AMC oversight – and pushing states to register and supervise larger firms – the rule:
-
Hardens expectations around valuer competence and independence;
-
Brings the AMC layer firmly within the post-crisis Dodd-Frank architecture; and
-
Raises the compliance bar for any firm that wants to sit between lenders and valuers on federally related mortgage business.
For compliance teams at banks and AMCs, the practical task is clear: treat the federal minimums as a baseline, build processes and documentation to prove you meet them, and keep a close eye on how individual states continue to refine their own AMC regimes on top.
